Back to research

Case Studies

Real-World Case Study: U.S. Tax-Exempt Organizations & Executive Compensation Under New IRS Notice

IRS’s Notice 2026-36 under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill significantly expands how excise tax on executive pay applies—learn via a detailed case study what this will mean for nonprofits and charities.

By Nomadic Tax Institute research team · 5-8 min read · Created

Background: What’s changing for tax-exempt organizations

Under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill (OBBB), the IRS has broadened the scope of the excise tax on excessive compensation and “excess parachute payments” for tax-exempt organizations (ATEOs). Notice 2026-36 announced proposed regulations to expand the definition of covered employee beyond simply the top five highest paid—now any employee with compensation over USD 1 million per year may be affected. Volunteering roles and certain exceptions for non-exempt funds or limited hours may still apply. (irs.gov)

Case: CharityPlus—a nonprofit in the U.S.

Scenario: CharityPlus, a mid-sized nonprofit, with 8 employees. Two executives make USD 1.2 million/year, and one mid-ranking senior manager makes USD 950,000. Under prior rules, only the top five highest-paid employees are “covered employees.” Under the new proposal, both executives are covered, and possibly the senior manager if including parachute or termination payments pushes total compensation above USD 1 million.

Potential implications

  • CharityPlus might owe excise tax on excess compensation (amounts above “reasonable” compensation thresholds) for both executives.
  • If there are parachute payments (severance or termination pay linked to change in control or similar events), they could attract additional tax as “excess parachute payments”.
  • Must ensure careful documentation of board and compensation committees and limit generous severance arrangements.

How nonprofits can prepare

  • Conduct compensation benchmarking: Ensure salaries are justified based on size, mission, comparable nonprofits.
  • Audit severance agreements and parachute pay clauses: Limit excess payments and ensure good governance.
  • Review volunteer policies: Ensure that exceptions for volunteer work are properly documented so exempt from these rules when applicable.
  • Monitor proposed regulations: IRS has requested comments; nonprofits should consider filing or coordinating comments to shape final rules. (irs.gov)
  • Incorporate in budgeting: Estimate potential excise tax exposure, including compensation above thresholds, to forecast financial impact.

Key takeaways

  • The expansion means more employees may be classified as covered and thus subject to excise tax rules.
  • Governance and documentation are critical—boards should review compensation policies now.
  • Nonprofits previously safe under “top five” may now find multiple employees subject to excise tax in a single year—so risk management matters.
  • Proposed rules are not yet final—stakeholder comments due date was August 4, 2026—but affected entities should begin preparing now. (irs.gov)

Sources

Existing article citations

Structured source metadata was not recorded for this historic item. Links below were cited in the article body.

treasury-irs-announce-intent-to-issue-proposed-regulations-for-… (www.irs.gov)